Recently spent a couple of expensive nights at the Atlantic Terrace. $250+ per night in July. Place needed a good overhaul, especially for the price. It was 2-3 stars, barely above a roadside motel level. Room was clean, but musky, and there was trouble locking the windows and sliding doors. The beach is more suited to surfing than swimming. Staff... more

Having been to Montauk many times we have found a great location with the best value. Our room had access to the terrace from the beach and an ocean view steps away from the pool. There is good security, and grounds keepers, a great place for families as well as couples. The common areas were great for sitting around the... more

MY boyfriend and I love going to Montauk off-season. We like the quiet and lack of crowds. The Atlantic Terrace has lovely grounds and the pool is practically right on the beach. We booked a standard efficiency room w/two beds and full bath on the second floor. Private balcony. I am diabetic and prefer to cook my own breakfast due... more

our family has been going to Montauk for years, and tried many hotels. we've finally found the perfect location on the beach. we've always stayed in the ocean front hotels near town, and always felt very crowed on the beach. the Atlantic Terrace is the last hotel on the beach, which made it seem very private. the kids had a... more

8 of us went to celebrate our fortieth bday! We had a great time even in the rainy weather.... Montauk standards are different as many places are run down. This place was clean, neat, with easy beach access and a lot of common areas for sitting. Indoor game room....Coffee shop cafe was wondeful with friendly staff.... more

I have been going to Montauk for the past 20 years and this is one of the nicer places. Pleasant staff. The garden view with the pool near and overlooking the ocean room is a must. The cafe was good. The coffee was great. A lot of partying families which what this place was made for. Sitting on a terrace... more

We had a blast! Our room was great. We stayed in room 209 which had a view of the pool and ocean. Our stay coincided with Rosh Hashanah which is a school holiday so we had alot of families and kids but were never bothered by noise. Our room was clean and comfy with a kitchenette and 2 beds. The... more

This place is okay at best. It's wonderful for families to come with a group of other families or relatives. There are a ton of teenagers running around, starting bonfires on the beach. We saw a ton of kids with their parents and uncles and aunts. But, because there aren't a lot of hotels out on Montauk, this motel is... more

Our kids loved Montauk. The surf was great and the location of the Atlantic Terrace was perfect...right on the beach. I was troubled though by the absence of lifeguards. There are signs posted at the gate on the property stating that you swim at your own risk, or rather 'no swimming'...no lifeguards. I know this is to cover themselves, but... more