Okay, I know the title is corny. I moved to Seattle three years ago and have yet to find a pizza that compares to Old Chicago's pizza. EVERY time I come back to Petaluma to visit I hit Old Chicago Pizza. I know it's going to be a long wait, so I plan accordingly. I love the atmosphere of the... more

Great pizza but plan on waiting a while for the food to arrive (or call order in ahead of time) more

BEST PIZZA more

These pizzas are so loaded with cheese they are absolute gut bombs. One piece is plenty. Good for deep dish style. more

thick and gooey pizza. perfect for a hangover. more

You'd better be hungry! more

this place is so yummy italia homestyle pizza!!!! love it as death! more

for-here or to-go, it's yummy comfort food. though I prefer to eat there and gaze out the huge windows overlooking the boulevard. more

A friend once told me before I first visited that once I have Old Chicago Pizza all other pizza will never be the same. Boy was he right. Old Chicago Pizza in my new standard for great pizza. I absolutely love eating their pizza for it's a pure treat every time. more