This Irish pub is five blocks or so from Duval, but it's a very short walk and worth it. Unlike certain Key West bars with "Irish" in the name that aren't Irish at all, Finnegan's Wake has probably the best selection of beers on the island, and a huge list of authentic Irish dishes (and some American dishes with Irish... more

OK I may be biased because I live only a few blocks away from Finnegan's - but it truly is THE best Irish pub in Key West. It's got great beer (I think it has the largest selection of beer on tap in Key West) - always served at the ideal temp and in the appropriate glass - no chintzy... more

Tasty Irish fair and fair prices, and the best beer selection in Key West. more

I spend hours in this building every week. i love the food, the burgers are great, the pizza is good, the wings, if i am real hungry the meatloaf and pork from corkrock out hard as well as the mac n cheese. they pour a good drink, the red sox are always on and the staff is pretty ok i... more

Finnigan's Wake was recommended by some of our local friends and we met them there for dinner. This is comfort food at its finest. There was so much we wanted to try! We started with a huge pile of onion rings, yummy! I decided on the special "Give em the finger" grouper fingers with the hot & sweet dipping sauce.... more

When you can't take any more of the Island theme bars, take refuge in Finnigans! They serve Murphy's Irish stout which is my husband's fav and the food was excellent. I felt like I was back in Ireland. more

Key West is blessed with many fine eating places. Finnigan's Wake is one of them. Looking much like a pub from the old country, the menu os quite unexpected. While it includes some "Pub" regulars (Bangers and Mash, Mac and Cheese) they also feature specials which change monthly. And don't miss the banana dessert! more

Finnegan's Wake is the perfect place under these scenarios: 1. It is freakishly chilly in KW and you need a warm cozy spot; 2. You are looking for a change of pace or break from rowdy pink-flamingo party spots; 3. You're curious about or enjoy locals hangouts when traveling; 4. You've had enough seafood and looking for a little "comfort... more

We stopped in based on recommendations from this website. The food, atmosphere and customers were great! The locals frequent this pub because they know it's among the best on the island. They even had my favorite English cider. We took our 16 month old daughter, she loved the mac and cheese! Highly recommended!! more