A cab driver recommended this place (they always know where to find great food at great prices) and it was a ... well, great ... recommendation. We went twice during the week we were in KW and will certainly visit next time we are in town. It's a neighborhood reatsurant, so don't expect anything fancy - just good, honest comfort... more

We met up with friends in Key West and they brought us here. We were concerned as it was off the beaten path. But we were wrong. The food was great!! I couldn't eat it all. It was the rolls that did me in. They are to die for. Put it on the top of the list for restaurants if... more

My husband surprised me with a birthday weekend in the Keys. Born and raised in FL and it took 39 years to get to the Keys! I wanted to eat the best food while there for 2 whole days! I read many reviews regarding restaurants. We ate at El Siboney Friday night 10/3/08. We rode our bikes past the restaurant... more

Thanks to the crew on our Danger Charter for for this great recommendation. Off the beaten path is right - it was definitely a hike from mallory square, but totally worth it. We split a pitcher of sangria, my husband had the skirt steak dinner, I had the roasted port & tamale dinner and we had way too much! We... more

This restaurant seems very authentic. It is off the beaten path in Key West and tucked away in a neighborhood. Great food, pleasant staff, average atmosphere (looks like every other mexican place). We recommend the grouper and the tostones. more

This was by far the best food we had on our trip to Key West. We had the bread to start and a 1/2 craf of sangria. We split a cuban sandwich and the # 3 plate with pork, tamali and some other potato/starch item. This is a great change from all the seafood we had been eating. I normally... more

This restaurant was recommended to us from each of the three places we stayed while we were in Key West. And now I know why. El Siboney is delicious! The staff is super friendly, the food is amazing, and the restaurant is very comfy. And the best part, the prices are very reasonable. more

i found El Siboney to be about average. The service was good and the food was edible but to a person who has never had Cuban food in there life, this would be good, but to someone who has tried Cuban cuisine in the past or is Cuban this place will not make you happy. more

This is our second trip to the Keys and our first visit to El Siboney. We went there for lunch. I had the special of the day the ox tail which was unbelievable. My wife had the grilled snapper which was so simply done--it was perfect. We shared a bowl of their lima bean soup, which was huge and delicious.... more