We used to frequent this place often when it was 309 First Street. Now it has changed hands and names and is Table Fifty. The inside is very intimate - dimly lit, with beautiful copper tables and candles.
Our table shared 4 appetizers - the pulled pork bbq in puff pastry with goat cheese, the scallops, the tuna tartare and the bbq shrimp. Each was delicious. The bbq appetizer was a pretty large size for an appetizer - there was tons of chunks of bbq and the combination of that and the goat cheese was unique.The scallops were out of this world - big and tender, the creamy, buttery & garlicky sauce swaddling the scallops was delectable (perfect for dipping your bread in!).The tuna tartare was also nice - very fresh and light. Bbq shrimp were subtley sweet, but spicy and you could tell the bbq sauce was homemade.
As far as our entrees, our table had the filet, the lobster tail, the crab cakes and the special which was a dry aged ribeye. The steaks were cooked to perfection. The lobster tail was amazing. And the crabcakes were wonderful - lots of lump crab & little filler. Portions were a good size. None of us could decide which entree was the best!!
We finished our amazing meal with the creme brulee duo - one regular and one chocolate. Delicious!!
The wine list is small but has a nice variety of choices (both varietals & prices). Very reasonable wine prices.
The service was amazing. Never had a glass empty and our waitress constantly checked on us to make sure everything was to our satisfaction and that we did not need anything. The restaurant was packed (a large prom group there as well) and yet it still seemed like we were the only ones there as far as service was concerned.
Everything exceeded our expectations. We cannot wait to return!!




