My husband and I had a wonderful lunch at the Old Chickahominy House on July 20, 2008. I had read the reviews here before we went and almost did not eat here because of some of the reviews that we read. We just had to write our own review because our experience there was so wonderful!
The restaurant was very busy when we arrived, but we were very graciously greeted and we put our names on the list. We were told that our wait could be as long as 40 minutes to an hour - but this was no problem because we really enjoyed shopping in their gift shop while we waited (we were delighted to find many treasures which they said that they could hold and we could pay for them when we paid for our meals). We waited for approximately 45 minutes when our name was finally called. We loved the atmosphere - it is like an old plantation or tavern - and this restaurant is not like eating "chain" food - it is good down-home southern Virginia regional cooking. If you are looking for area flavor while you are on vacation and something out of the ordinary - then this is the place for you!!! Both of us got the Miss Melinda's Special which is a cup of brunswick stew (nether of us had brunswick stew before - but both of us LOVED it - and we could also have gotten a bowl instead of a cup for an additional charge), old virginia ham on hot biscuits (the ham was wonderful and tasty and the biscuits were stretched out long - like bread and just WONDERFUL - melt in your mouth - we have never had anything else like them - they come plain - but condiments are given on request), fruit salad (the fruit has a special dressing that we think was possibly sour cream & cream cheese mixed together), homemade pie (we chose blackberry and it was just FANTASTIC), and coffee or tea (we had the iced tea and it was WONDERFUL). It is not a huge lunch - but certainly filled up both of us.
Both of us keep commenting to each other what a special and different lunch we had at the Old Chickahominy House and that we will certainly return there again the next time that we are in Williamsburg.




